Multiple Denial of Service (DoS) Vulnerabilities in HTTP/2 Disclosed (CVE-2019-9511, CVE-2019-9518)

Satnam Narang

A variety of Denial of Service vulnerabilities were found in third-party implementations of HTTP/2.

Background

On August 13, researchers at Netflix published an advisory for their GitHub page detailing their discovery of eight vulnerabilities in the HTTP/2 protocol implementations by third parties. The vulnerabilities were primarily discovered by Jonathan Looney, Engineering Manager at Netflix, with one vulnerability, CVE-2019-9518, discovered by Piotr Sikora, Senior Software Engineer at Google.

Multiple Denial of Service (DoS) Vulnerabilities in HTTP/2 Disclosed (CVE-2019-9511, CVE-2019-9518)

Image Credit: Cloudflare

Analysis

A client (“the attacker”) can exploit these HTTP/2 vulnerabilities by sending specially crafted requests to vulnerable servers. While these requests will vary, a vulnerable server will attempt to process the request and attempt to send a response. However, the malicious client ignores the response, leading to excess consumption of resources, which would result in a denial of service (DoS).

The following are the eight vulnerabilities and the associated nicknames given to them in the Netflix advisory.

CVE ID Nickname CVE-2019-9511 “Data Dribble” CVE-2019-9512 “Ping Flood” CVE-2019-9513 “Resource Loop” CVE-2019-9514 “Reset Flood” CVE-2019-9515 “Settings Flood” CVE-2019-9516 “0-Length Headers Leak” CVE-2019-9517 “Internal Data Buffering” CVE-2019-9518 “Empty Frames Flood”

Proof of concept

At the time the blog was published, no proof-of-concept code was available.

Solution

To immediately address the vulnerabilities, Netflix’s advisory suggests disabling HTTP/2 support, but cautions that this could either result in performance degradation or not be feasible. Software vendors are in the process of publishing patches for these vulnerabilities. Initial reports from vendors can be found below:

Vendor Link(s) Source Akamai HTTP2 Vulnerabilities Blog Ambassador (API Gateway) Multiple HTTP/2 vulnerabilities in Envoy Proxy Blog Apache Traffic Server (ATS) [ANNOUNCE] Apache Traffic Server is vulnerable to various HTTP/2 attacks Mailing List Cloudflare On the recent HTTP/2 DoS attacks Blog Envoy (Proxy) Version 1.11.1 History Changelog Google (Golang) [security] Go 1.12.8 and Go 1.11.13 are released Forum Posting Microsoft CVE-2019-9511, CVE-2019-9512, CVE-2019-9513, CVE-2019-9514, CVE-2019-9518 Advisory Netty Project Netty 4.1.39.Final released Blog nghttp2 nghttp2 v1.39.2 Release Notes Software Release Nginx NGINX Updates Mitigate the August 2019 HTTP/2 Vulnerabilities Blog Node.js August 2019 Security Releases Blog Swift About the security content of SwiftNIO HTTP/2 1.5.0 Advisory

Customers using these software applications are encouraged to update to the patched versions as soon as possible.

Identifying affected systems

A list of Tenable plugins to identify these vulnerabilities will appear here as they’re released.

Get more information

Join Tenable's Security Response Team on the Tenable Community.

Learn more about Tenable, the first Cyber Exposure platform for holistic management of your modern attack surface.

Get a free 60-day trial of Tenable.io .

Read more >

Published on Aug 14, 2019

People also viewed

Software Engineer - Web Scraping (Python)

Baltimore Maryland United States Baltimore, Maryland, United States Research Engineering
Your Role:Tenable is looking for a Software Engineer to join our Automation research team.  This position will involve building and maintaining our framework for automated content creation, validation, and deliveryYour Opportunity: Impact: You wi...

Sales Development Representative - UK Region

Staines upon Thames Surrey United Kingdom Staines upon Thames, Surrey, United Kingdom Lead Generation Sales
Your Role:The Sales Development Representative supports remote sales teams in and is responsible for generating new business via inbound and outbound phone opportunity qualification.Your Opportunity: Perform outbound calling to generate new sales ...

Senior UI Engineer

Dublin Ireland Campshires, Sir John Rogerson's Quay, Dublin, Ireland Engineering Engineering
Your Role:Are you excited about the opportunity to build user interfaces used by some of the biggest corporations in the world? Do you like knowing that the changes that you deploy to production will improve the customer experience of many users w...

Research Manager

Columbia Maryland United States Columbia Gateway Drive, Columbia, Maryland, United States, 21046 Research Research
Your Role:Tenable is looking for a Research Manager to head our Web Scraping research team. You will manage a highly focused team of engineers building and maintaining web scrapers for automated ingestion of vulnerability intelligence as well as t...

Research Manager

Denver Colorado United States Denver, Colorado, United States Research Research
Your Role:Tenable is looking for a Research Manager to head our Web Scraping research team. You will manage a highly focused team of engineers building and maintaining web scrapers for automated ingestion of vulnerability intelligence as well as t...

Research Manager

Detroit Michigan United States Detroit, Michigan, United States Research Research
Your Role:Tenable is looking for a Research Manager to head our Web Scraping research team. You will manage a highly focused team of engineers building and maintaining web scrapers for automated ingestion of vulnerability intelligence as well as t...

We have big plans for continued global growth, and we’re looking for people who are creative, flexible and dedicated to helping us build something great – something that matters.